Audit, competition and serving shareholders

14 March 2013

Sarah Wilson

EU regulation

Last week, the UK Competition Commission published its provisional findings in its investigation into the provision of statutory audit services in the UK. Unsurprisingly, the findings show that there are obstacles to competition, as if we didn't know that already. Just in case you needed more evidence, some really interesting research in this month's Financial Director magazine's 2013 Audit Survey shows just how much harder the 'fifth' audit company has to work compared to the average of the big four . In fact, that's not the real story here, reassuring though it is that genuine competition in the provision of such an important service is firmly on the agenda now.

Reform in the audit market has long been needed. Investor-led proposals for audit reform were eloquently posited in November last year by a group of institutional shareholders and organisations spanning across borders, asset owners and managers alike. This, too, is not the real story, encouraging as it was to see investors organically working together to articulate their collective views on an issue important to shareholders in a collective 'public engagement'.

The real story, and the important link between these two developments, lies in the comments made by Laura Carstensen, Chairman of the Audit Investigation Group. In characterising the dynamics and effect of the audit selection process, she observed that "the result is a rather static market in which too often audits don’t fulfil their intended purpose and thus fail to meet the needs of shareholders".

And there it is, the central governance priority writ large: "The needs of shareholders".

Latest News

SHareholder meeting

Accountability Versus Allocation: Who Is Corporate Reporting For?

SHareholder meeting

SFDR Review Moves Forward, But Key Questions Remain for Investors

SHareholder meeting

German governance code reform: Minerva supports simplification, but draws a line at investor visibility

SHareholder meeting

FRC’s new regulatory approach signals a shift from rule-making to market stewardship

SHareholder meeting

Shein lists in Hong Kong at reduced valuation after protracted IPO journey

SHareholder meeting

SEC sends executive pay disclosure overhaul to White House for review

Featured Briefings

Minerva Briefing

Shareholder Proposal Voting Trends 2026 H1

Minerva Briefing

Virtual-Only AGMs

Minerva Briefing

UK Proxy Season Review 2026

Minerva is a global provider of sustainable stewardship solutions with over 30 years of expertise. Minerva empowers investors by providing essential tools, including ESG research and data and expert insights, enabling them to navigate the intricate and ever-evolving landscape of stewardship and proxy voting, whilst ensuring their decisions are well-informed and aligned with sustainable principles.

Related Stories

FRC

FRC’s new regulatory approach signals a shift from rule-making to market stewardship

September 4, 2026
Read More
SEC axes Rule 14a-8 ‘no action’ process for shareholder proposals

SEC axes Rule 14a-8 ‘no action’ process for shareholder proposals

August 20, 2026
Read More
Wise faces shareholder lawsuit soon after controversial US shift

Wise faces shareholder lawsuit soon after controversial US shift

August 14, 2026
Read More
Texas Stock Exchange voting proposal could reshape shareholder influence

Texas Stock Exchange voting proposal could reshape shareholder influence

August 6, 2026
Read More
China sharpens the lens on financial institution governance

China sharpens the lens on financial institution governance

August 4, 2026
Read More
Nike climate proposal

Shareholders challenge Nike on emissions reduction efforts

July 30, 2026
Read More